Online Video Game Rental By Mail - Quick Chart

Rated Service Overall Signup Price Games Delivery Service Trial
#1
video game rental
$7.95
+/- 7,000
Fast
video game rental
Free
#2
video game rentalvideo game rental
$8.99
+/- 7,000
Fast
None
#3
$14.95
+/- 1,600
Average
None

* Cost: $15.95/mo - 1 Game Out
* Over 7000 Titles
* Games Arrive In 2-4 Days
* Free 10 Day Trial
* Xbox, Xbox 360, PSP, PS2, PS3, Game Cube, Game Boy Advanced, Nintendo Wii, & Nintendo DS
* Email Support

Background on GameFly:

GameFly is currently the biggest online video game rental company in the US, and they have been doing business since 2002. They offer new members a ten day free trial for a two games at a time plan ($22.95/mo thereafter), or the chance of getting the first month's membership at $8.95 for one game at a time or $12.95 for two games at a time. The prices after the free trial incentive ends are:

• $15.95 per month for one game at a time
• $22.95 per month for two games at a time
• $29.95 per month for three games at a time (although this option requires the member to have an active account of good standing for sixty days or more)
• $36.95 per month for four games at a time (as above)

There is no long-term commitment and can cancel, upgrade or downgrade any time you want – no questions asked. Just go into “My Account” on your membership page, choose “Change My Membership Plan,” and you are good to go. Read the rest of this entry

* Cost: Starts at $8.99/mo
* 7000+ Titles
* Buy, Trade, and Rent Video Games
* Free Shipping on all transactions
* All consoles
* Customer Service 561-450-5123 – (Mon – Sat, 11AM – 5PM)

Gamemine.com is an up and coming service that continues to make improvements that make this a serious contender in the game rental market. Here's a breakdown of their service:

When you sign up with Gamemine, you are prompted to fill up your queue (which they call your "minelist") with your desired games. As a game becomes available it will be shipped to you and once you return it you receive the next game in your queue. Your very first game is sent with a delivery confirmation from USPS. Your card is charged when the game is sent out to you. Everyone’s game is tracked throughout the mail system until delivered.

In the past Gammine offered a 2x speed option for members who remained active for over 3 months. They have recently implemented the 2x speed option for everyone on the first day of service. 2x speed basically means that you can have your next game mailed out as soon as your last game is put in the mail. This significantly reduces your waiting time for games. Gamemine claims that their 2x speed delivery system is twice as fast as any other game rental service.

Gamemine's website is very user-friendly and games are broken out into browse-able categories that you can sort by things like console, game title, release date, publisher and more. They have a real decent selection of over 7000 titles and growing fast. At the top of each category page they feature the most popular games for that category and below each individual game you will see other recommendations i.e. "You Might Also Like". This is just a handy feature to stay on top of new releases or games that you might not have heard about. They also recently added a new filter system for searching for games of your choice such as Genres, Date Released, User Rating, Buy Price, Trade Price, Rent Availability, ESBR Ratings, and Coming Soon. For your trades, you can simply input the UPC or Title of the game to see how much it is worth. Although you initially pay for the shipping, the cost will be credited to your account once the game is received. All purchased games are shipped for free.

Gamemine is one of the few services that does offer parental control features which enable parents to block unwanted games by rating or genre. With this feature it's really easy to keep your kids playing games appropriate for their age range. Gamemine also offers the you the ability to rent movies in PSP format. The selection of titles isn't massive but a number of the big ones.

They now offer live customer service allowing you to speak with a representative for any questions about your account. In addition Live chat and email customer service are available as well. The customer service hours are from Monday through Saturday from 11AM to 5PM. The customer service phone number is 561-450-5123.

User's are not required to opt-in to the rental service in order to sign up for gamemine.com. You can participate in purchasing and trading in games without having the rental service.

It's not surprising that this company is really growing their customer base as it delivers really decent service at a good price.


Disclosure of Material Connection: Some of the links in the post above are “affiliate links.” This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, I will receive an affiliate commission. Regardless, I only recommend products or services I use personally and believe will add value to my readers. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”

•    No free trial
•    $14.95 for one game for the first month; $17.95 each month thereafter
•    Offers Wii, Nintendo DS, PSP, Playstation, Playstation 2, Playstation 3, Xbox, and Xbox 360 games
•    Shipping time: one to two days
•    2,400+ titles available

Gamerang Review:

There are many different video game rental sites out there, and Gamerang is yet another of them.  The company features distribution centers spread across the United States—California, New Jersey, Oklahoma, and Minnesota, to be exact.  This means your games will ship from the closest distribution center to minimize shipping time.  There are no late fees or return dates.

There is no free trial or money-back guarantee, but your first month is only $14.95 for one game out.  It’s $17.95 for each additional month.  If you want two games a month, it’s $24.95.  Three games are $49.95, and four games are $59.95.  After that, you can add an addition game up to ten games for $9.95 a title.  The site currently has a two month special for $40.  They also give you a year’s subscription to Wired Magazine if you spend more than $9.95, which means you get the subscription no matter which monthly package you take. Read the rest of this entry